In the fascinating world of rare coins, some pieces become legendary not because they were intended to be special—but because of mistakes. One such prized coin is the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel, a U.S. coin that gained massive popularity due to a unique minting error at the Denver Mint. With collectors willing to pay as much as six figures for a pristine example, this coin is now one of the most sought-after error coins in American numismatic history.
Its rarity, visual uniqueness, and compelling backstory make it an iconic treasure for collectors. But how did it happen, and what makes it so valuable today?
The Story Behind the Buffalo Nickel
The Buffalo Nickel, also called the Indian Head Nickel, was first introduced in 1913 and remained in circulation until 1938, when it was replaced by the Jefferson Nickel. Designed by James Earle Fraser, it aimed to celebrate America’s native heritage and frontier spirit.
- Front (Obverse): A striking portrait of a Native American, based on a blend of real tribal leaders.
- Back (Reverse): A powerful American buffalo, believed to be modeled after a bison named Black Diamond from New York’s Central Park Zoo.
Despite its cultural significance, the Buffalo Nickel series had several design flaws that led to frequent die wear—setting the stage for one of the most well-known minting errors in U.S. history.
How Did the Three-Legged Error Happen?
By 1937, the dies used at the Denver Mint to strike Buffalo Nickels were wearing out. Instead of replacing the dies, a mint worker over-polished one of them, accidentally removing the front right leg of the buffalo on the reverse side.
This wasn’t a minor flaw. The buffalo clearly looks like it has only three legs, making the error highly visible even to the naked eye. With no automated quality control at the time, several thousand of these flawed nickels entered circulation unnoticed.
The mistake turned what would’ve been a routine coin into a legendary collector’s item.
Why This Coin Is Worth Thousands
The 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel is valuable for multiple reasons:
- Striking Visual Error: Unlike other minor mint errors, the missing leg is highly noticeable, adding to its collectability.
- Low Survival Rate: Only a limited number were produced before the mistake was caught. Most of those saw heavy circulation.
- Rising Collector Demand: Error coins are a major category in numismatics. This nickel is one of the crown jewels in that group.
- Historic Significance: It represents a time when minting wasn’t as precise, yet these imperfections created history.
This coin has become synonymous with rare American minting errors, often featured in exhibits and auctions worldwide.
How to Spot an Authentic 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel
Because of its popularity, many counterfeits exist. If you come across a Buffalo Nickel and wonder if it’s the real deal, check for these features:
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Missing Front Right Leg | The buffalo’s right front leg is entirely missing, though a small trace of the hoof may remain. |
| Denver Mint Mark | A small “D” under the buffalo, just below “Five Cents.” |
| Polishing Marks | The area around the stomach and legs appears unusually smooth due to over-polishing. |
Steps to Verify:
- Use a 10x magnifier to inspect the missing leg and mint mark.
- Compare the coin with reference images from trusted coin catalogs.
- Get the coin professionally graded by agencies like PCGS or NGC for accurate authentication.
What’s the Value of This Rare Nickel in 2025?
The price of a 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel depends on its condition (grade) and authenticity. Here’s what collectors are paying today:
| Coin Grade | Estimated Value (2024–2025) |
|---|---|
| Good (G4) | $200 – $500 |
| Very Fine (VF20) | $900 – $1,500 |
| About Uncirculated (AU55) | $1,250 – $2,000 |
| Mint State (MS63) | $5,000 – $9,000 |
| Mint State (MS67) | $85,000 – $100,000+ |
Recent Notable Sales:
- In 2008, a high-grade MS67 coin sold for $1.5 million at a premier auction.
- In 2021, a Mint State specimen sold for just under $100,000.
Even heavily worn examples can fetch over $1,000, making it one of the most valuable error nickels ever produced.
How to Store and Protect a Rare Coin Like This
Preserving the coin’s value is as important as owning it. Here’s how to do it safely:
| Storage Option | Protection Level |
|---|---|
| Certified Coin Holders (PCGS/NGC slabs) | Airtight, tamper-proof, best for high-value coins |
| Airtight Plastic Capsules | Shields against moisture, air, and dust |
| Safe Deposit Boxes | Ideal for long-term, high-value storage |
| Gloves for Handling | Always wear cotton or nitrile gloves to prevent fingerprints or oils from damaging the coin surface |
Avoid storing your coin in PVC holders or any environment with high humidity. Professional grading also improves resale value and protects the coin’s legitimacy.
FAQs
What makes the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel so rare?
The missing leg was the result of a minting error at the Denver Mint. Only a small number of these coins were released before the mistake was discovered.
How can I tell if my coin is a real three-legged nickel?
Look for the missing front right leg, the “D” mint mark, and signs of over-polishing. For confirmation, use a magnifier or get it graded by PCGS or NGC.
Can a damaged coin be mistaken for this error?
Yes, worn coins or counterfeits might appear similar. That’s why professional grading is highly recommended.
Is it still possible to find this coin in circulation?
Extremely unlikely. Most have been removed from circulation and are now in the hands of collectors or auction houses.
How much is the coin worth in worn condition?
Even in Good (G4) condition, it can be worth $200 to $500, depending on market demand.
Why wasn’t the error fixed immediately?
Back in 1937, the minting process lacked modern quality control. Since the coin still worked for transactions, the error went unnoticed for some time.
Has the value of this coin increased over time?
Yes. Due to rising collector interest and decreasing availability, its value has steadily climbed—especially for high-grade specimens.
Should I get my coin graded?
Absolutely. Grading ensures authenticity, confirms condition, and increases value if you ever plan to sell or insure it.
Click here to know more.
Aanchal is a passionate writer with a keen interest in storytelling, content creation, and creative expression. She enjoys exploring diverse topics and crafting engaging narratives that captivate readers.